top of page

Aioli, Mayonnaise and Hollandaise from Pasteurized Eggs

Jan 22, 2022
11 min read

In short: pasteurize eggs in their shell at 57°C (135°F) for 1 hour and 15 minutes, chill them in an ice bath, and use them to make safe homemade aioli, mayonnaise and hollandaise. A whisk is best for olive oil sauces, and an immersion blender is the quickest for mayo and hollandaise.

Most of us keep egg-based sauces like mayo/aioli at home. These sauces are pasteurized in advance and contain quite a few ingredients, which are there to add flavor but mainly to give them a long shelf life.

Although you can buy these sauces in any supermarket, in my opinion nothing beats the personal taste of a sauce made only with ingredients you know and without preservatives.

Thanks to sous vide, you can also make these sauces from pasteurized eggs right in your own kitchen.

This guide will show you how simple it is to make these sauces with the tools you already have at home.



What is pasteurization? (very briefly)

Uncooked food contains millions of microorganisms, some of which are responsible for spoilage or fermentation (the same probiotic bacteria that are good for our bodies), and some of which are pathogenic (meaning viruses, bacteria and parasites that can harm us).

These pathogens multiply within a certain temperature range - storing food in the fridge below 5°C (41°F) significantly slows their growth, while above a certain temperature, these pathogens stop growing and start to decrease and die (this is where pasteurization actually starts, and it lasts depending on thickness, time and temperature).

Pasteurization is actually a reduction of pathogens/bacteria by about 7 orders of magnitude (a probability of about 1 in a million), which makes the food safe to eat even for people with a weak immune system.

Pasteurization also extends the shelf life of food (as long as the food isn't exposed to air yet).

It's important to understand that pasteurization isn't sterilization, meaning there's still a chance of spores that can develop into bacteria in the future, within the danger zone.


How to pasteurize eggs in sous vide

Uncooked eggs can be a breeding ground for salmonella and listeria, since these bacteria can get through the shell, which is why health authorities recommend not eating uncooked eggs, especially for people with a weak immune system.

This is where one of the big advantages of sous vide comes in - with this method, you can pasteurize eggs at 57°C (135°F) for an hour and 15 minutes and lower the risk of eating uncooked eggs.

At 57°C, the white and the yolk don't cook yet, so you can pasteurize an egg in its shell without cooking it.

The white comes out slightly lighter and takes longer to whip, but the result should be the same as regular whipping.

When cooking in sous vide, put the whole egg into water preheated to 57°C.

I recommend putting the eggs in a zipper bag with a little water, using the water displacement method, so the eggs don't move around freely in the water bath or crack. After an hour and 15 minutes, move the eggs to an ice bath for about 20 minutes.

Store the eggs you're not using in the fridge.


Pasteurizing eggs in sous vide
Pasteurizing eggs in sous vide

Sous vide pasteurized egg vs. unpasteurized egg
Sous vide pasteurized egg vs. unpasteurized egg

The base of the sauces

All the sauces below have one thing in common, and that's the egg, or to be precise, the yolk.

Sauces like mayonnaise, aioli (at least the French Provençal version) and hollandaise are based on emulsification (= emulsion), meaning a process where ingredients that don't mix, like water and oil, manage to bind together into a uniform mixture, thanks to the lecithin molecule found in the yolk.


Oil and water don't mix
Oil and water don't mix


A few ways to create the emulsion and make the sauces

Whisk

A basic kitchen tool found in every home, made for quickly mixing and whipping liquids/eggs, and also handy for making sauces that need an emulsion. Whisking adds air, which makes the sauce lighter and gives you full control over the final texture and flavor. It's also the best method when using olive oil, because mixing too aggressively with blenders brings out the oil's bitterness. With this method, use a deep bowl set on a damp towel, which keeps the bowl steady while you whisk the sauce. First, add the yolk/egg, mustard, salt and pepper, and whisk well until uniform. Then start drizzling the oil down the sides of the bowl very slowly, while whisking the mixture the whole time. Once the mixture gets thicker, you can drizzle the oil in faster. Finally, add lemon/water/vinegar as needed, which lets you control the final texture - the more liquid you add, the lighter and runnier the texture. Today, you can speed up this process with an electric whisk (my favorite for making aioli) and work exactly the same way in less time.

Aioli made with a whisk
Aioli made with a whisk

Immersion blender

A handheld blender that helps us quickly grind and whip relatively small amounts without using a countertop blender. An immersion blender also comes with a narrow mixing cup that's just perfect for making the sauce. Because of its huge speed, making the sauce can take just 10 seconds, especially if you have a powerful immersion blender like a BAMIX. Pour all the ingredients into the narrow mixing cup and run it at the highest speed - within a few seconds, an emulsion forms at the bottom, and once mayonnaise has formed in two thirds of the cup, start slowly lifting the blender up. When working with an immersion blender, make sure the blenderhttps://link.amazon/A0gIlfNf0 head sits under the liquids, together with the vinegar or lemon and the egg, with the oil on top, so that as the blender works, the oil gradually gets drawn in to form the emulsion. This way, we mimic the manual action you saw in the previous method. Too little liquid or too much oil at the bottom can ruin the emulsion.

Mayonnaise made with a Bamix
Mayonnaise made with a Bamix

Food processor/countertop blender (Ninja-style) with a drizzle opening

With a countertop blender, you can make larger batches of sauce, and quickly too, thanks to its fast mixing. First, add the yolk/egg, mustard, salt and pepper, and blend for about half a minute until uniform. Then start adding the oil very slowly while the blender runs and mixes everything to create the emulsion. Finally, add lemon/water/vinegar as needed, which lets you control the final texture - the more liquid you add, the lighter and runnier the texture.

Mayonnaise made with a countertop blender
Mayonnaise made with a countertop blender

Food chopper

Even with a simple device like a food chopper, you can get the texture you want. First, add the yolk/egg, mustard, salt and pepper, and blend for about half a minute until uniform. Then add the oil in small portions, pulsing for 10 seconds each time. Repeat these pulses until you've added all the butter, without the milk solids. Finally, add lemon/water/vinegar as needed.

Hollandaise made with a food chopper
Hollandaise made with a food chopper

Aioli recipe

The word is made of two words (ali oli), which mean "garlic and oil" in Catalan and Italian

The traditional Catalan version of aioli is made only from olive oil and garlic (no yolk) and is made with a mortar and pestle to crush the garlic into a paste and then emulsify it with the olive oil - this gives you a paste-like sauce with very intense flavors. There are also French versions that use a yolk and neutral oil, where the garlic is the base, meaning garlic mayonnaise.

In my recipe, I tried to get more dominant flavors of olive oil, garlic and lemon, so it combines two oils (olive and neutral), but you can play with the amounts.


Ingredients

  • 1 egg yolk

  • ⅓ cup olive oil

  • ⅔ cup neutral oil, like canola

  • 4-6 garlic cloves (preferably garlic bought unpeeled)

  • 1 heaping teaspoon smooth Dijon mustard

  • ½ to 1 lemon

  • ½ to 1 teaspoon salt / to taste

  • ½ teaspoon black pepper / to taste

Recommended method

Because I'm using olive oil, I avoid using a blender, because mixing too aggressively brings out the oil's bitterness. That's why, when making aioli, I use a hand whisk or an electric whisk and that way I have precise control over both the flavor and the texture. First, I add the yolks, Dijon mustard, salt and pepper to the mixing bowl and whisk well.

Since I like a dominant garlic flavor in aioli, I add around 4-6 garlic cloves, and I focus on the following:

  1. I make sure to use garlic bought unpeeled because it has a more dominant aroma, and there's a scientific explanation for it - what gives garlic its dominant aroma is the allicin molecule, which forms when the garlic is crushed, and when we buy peeled garlic, this already happens at the factory, so the aroma will be less dominant.

  2. Remove the germ - every garlic clove has a germ growing in it, which is the source of acidity and bitterness, especially in fresh garlic, so I recommend removing it before using. Simply cut the clove in half and take the germ out with a knife. Not a must, but highly recommended.

  3. I crush the garlic cloves with a mortar and pestle until I get a paste.


Garlic germ
Garlic germ

Add the crushed garlic to the bowl and keep whisking.

Now start slowly pouring the olive oil down the sides of the bowl, so it gradually goes down and mixes with the liquids.

The reason for this is that right now the bowl has a yolk with a small amount of lecithin, which tries to bind to both water and oil - mixing in a small amount of oil breaks the oil up and creates a perfect bond, called an emulsion.

Over time, the mixture gets thicker and you can increase the amount of oil you add to the bowl.

The advantage of this method is that with a whisk we add a little air, which creates a lighter texture if that's what you're looking for, and of course, this way you have full control over the flavor.

Stop whisking once you get a thick mixture with dominant olive oil flavors, and now it's time to add the neutral oil.

At this stage, you can drizzle in the oil in larger amounts.

Toward the end, add lemon juice - half a lemon or a whole one, according to your taste - and keep whisking to the texture you want. Remember, aioli should be a bold sauce with a boost of bitterness and sourness.

Frena bread with lamb shoulder and aioli
Frena bread with lamb shoulder and aioli

Mayonnaise recipe

One of the popular stories about the origin of mayonnaise comes from the French victory in 1756, when they captured the city of Mahón (which sounds like the word mayo, meaning mayonnaise).

The French chef was asked to prepare a victory feast that was supposed to include a cream-based sauce.

Since there was no cream, the chef decided to improvise by whisking oil and eggs - and that's how the new sauce was born.

The chef decided to call the sauce Mahonnaise (after the port city), which over time became known around the world as Mayonnaise.


Ingredients

  • 1 cup neutral oil, like canola

  • 1 whole egg

  • 1 teaspoon Dijon mustard

  • 2 tablespoons vinegar

  • ½ teaspoon salt / to taste

  • ½ teaspoon black pepper / to taste

  • Water as needed for a lighter, runnier texture

Recommended method

Mayonnaise is easiest and quickest to make with an immersion blender - simply add all the ingredients, except the water, to the mixing cup.

I prefer to add the water at the end, so I can control the final texture of the mayonnaise precisely.

When working with an immersion blender, make sure the blender head sits under the liquids, together with the vinegar or lemon and the egg, with the oil on top, so that as the blender works, the oil gradually gets drawn in to form the emulsion. This way, you mimic the manual action of a whisk, just much faster.

Keep in mind that too little liquid or too much oil at the bottom can ruin the emulsion.

Finally, add lemon/water as needed, which lets you control the final texture - the more liquid you add, the lighter and runnier the texture.



Hollandaise recipe

The word means "Dutch sauce" in French, but that doesn't necessarily say where the sauce comes from.

A sauce with similar ingredients was already documented in the 17th century by François Pierre La Varenne in a recipe for asparagus with a "fragrant sauce", and the most popular theory has to do with recipes brought by French Protestants (the Huguenots) returning from exile in Holland.


Ingredients

  • 3 egg yolks

  • 1 tablespoon vinegar reduced with shallot

  • 140g melted butter

  • 1 tablespoon lemon juice

  • 1 teaspoon salt

  • At least 4 tablespoons water, to get the texture you want



Recommended method

Unlike the other sauces here, hollandaise is based on a warm emulsion, so it's harder to make the traditional way and it's important to eat it while it's still warm.

If you're looking for an "everything in the bag in sous vide" recipe, check out the eggs Benedict recipe here on the blog.

In my opinion, the most convenient and safest way to make hollandaise is with an immersion blender.

First, chop the shallot and cook it in a pot with white wine vinegar over medium heat until it boils and the liquid reduces by half, to concentrate all the flavors into a sweet and sour liquid.

Melt the butter in a pot or in the microwave until it boils - it's important for the butter to be hot.

Put all the ingredients except the butter into the mixing cup.

Start blending for 20-30 seconds until uniform.

Now slowly start pouring in the hot butter, a little at a time, until only the milk solids are left.

It's very important to keep blending and moving the immersion blender up and down to make sure the emulsion forms successfully.

To keep the sauce warm, you can transfer it to a thermos until serving.



Eggs Benedict with hollandaise
Eggs Benedict with hollandaise

Did your emulsion break? You can still fix it

If your emulsion breaks, simply take another mixing bowl and put a yolk in it. Now, with a whisk/blender, mix well and start slowly adding the broken emulsion, a little at a time - we're basically doing the process again, but this time with what we already have.



Frequently asked questions

Does using a blender make olive oil bitter?

Usually, fast mechanical blending makes olive oil bitter. Using a whisk prevents this. You can read the in-depth comparison on Serious Eats

Does pasteurization extend shelf life?

Once you crack the egg, according to the FDA, mayonnaise has a shelf life of up to 4 days in the fridge.

What actually extends the shelf life is the acidity of the mayonnaise, meaning ingredients like lemon juice and vinegar.

Personally, I use sauces like mayonnaise and aioli for up to 5 days.

How long can you store a pasteurized egg?

According to the FDA:

In-shell pasteurized eggs must be stored in the refrigerator and may be used within three to five weeks. Unopened pasteurized liquid egg substitutes may be stored in the refrigerator for 10 days; use opened cartons within three days after opening. Freezing egg substitutes is not recommended; however, egg products purchased frozen may be kept in the freezer up to one year

Which garlic should you use?

Fresh, unpeeled garlic has the most dominant aroma and, in my opinion, is the best for sauces like aioli.

What gives garlic its dominant aroma is the allicin molecule, which forms when the garlic is crushed, and when we buy peeled garlic, this already happens at the factory, which affects the aroma.

How important is it to remove the germ described in the recipe?

It's not a must at all, and I recommend trying it with and without the germ, just like in the comparison test done by Serious Eats

So what's the difference between mayonnaise and aioli?

While the emulsion process both sauces go through is similar, the result is very different in flavor.

Mayonnaise is made with neutral oil, so its flavors are very mild and its texture is smooth.

Aioli is made with olive oil and garlic, which create very dominant flavors, so you get a more yellowish sauce, and even a paste-like one if you go with a traditional recipe.

How do you control the texture?

By adjusting the amount of liquids like water, vinegar and lemon juice, you can control how light/runny the sauce is.



Worth reading

A taste comparison with and without garlic germs

A scientific article on acidity for extending shelf life

An article on the effect of vacuum cooking on reducing salmonella (pasteurization)

Baldwin's article on pasteurizing eggs in sous vide

Allicin




Comments


CONTACT ME

SUBSCRIBE VIA EMAIL

Success! Message received.

  • telegram
  • YouTube

The Casual Sous Vider | אדי רוזנבלט | בלוג סו-ויד ישראלי

COPYRIGHT © 2022 Eddie Rozenblat | sousvideer.com

For privacy policy click here

bottom of page