de Buyer Mineral B Carbon Steel Pan Review
In short: the de Buyer Mineral B carbon steel pan weighs about half as much as my cast iron pan (2.1 kg vs. 3.5 kg), heats up fast and gives an amazing sear after sous vide. It needs seasoning just like cast iron, and its coated handle limits it to 10 minutes in the oven above 200°C (390°F).
Until now, I used a smooth cast iron pan, which gave perfect results when searing cuts after cooking them sous vide or with the reverse sear, but its excessive weight (3.5 kg!), together with a short handle that isn't very comfortable to use, always made cleaning and maintenance (burning on a thin layer of oil) harder, so I switched to a stainless steel pan.
The stainless steel pan didn't disappoint in terms of results either, but after searing meat, the pan always looked like it had been cooked in for years, so I had to spend a lot of time scrubbing and cleaning it.
So how do you get the best of both worlds? Is there a pan that's lighter, comfortable to use and can also reach a high temperature for a perfect sear in a short time?
This is where the carbon steel pan comes in.
What is seasoning?
Cast iron and carbon steel pans are made of steel that's sensitive to moisture/water, so to keep them from rusting, these pans need a maintenance process called seasoning (coating).
This process also creates a non-stick layer that lets you fry omelets and pancakes (and even pizza).


Initial seasoning of a carbon steel pan
Carbon steel pans usually come with a layer of wax (in this case, beeswax) that keeps them from rusting while stored before their first use.
These pans also usually come without any seasoning (coating) and look almost identical to a stainless steel pan (silver and shiny).
You can find the initial seasoning and maintenance process in the cast iron and carbon steel pan care guide

What's special about cast iron and carbon steel pans?
These pans are great at conducting (mainly carbon steel) and retaining heat, which makes them ideal for searing meat, especially after sous vide.
Both need the same cleaning and maintenance - rinsing, scrubbing with boiling water (a quick wash with soap and water is fine too) and coating with oil to keep the pans from rusting.
Both can become non-stick over time, although I found it much easier with the carbon steel pan, which comes much smoother to begin with than a cast iron pan.
With proper use, these pans can last for decades, if not generations.
You can repeat this process after every use, although it's really not a must.
The initial seasoning process, searing and cleaning after use
The first days of use
One of the tests for how effective the non-stick layer is, is frying a sunny-side-up egg/omelet (with butter, of course), where the egg slides around the pan easily.
Before going for this test, I decided to sear and fry a few things first to get a perfect non-stick layer.
First, I seared asado bites, a reverse-seared burger (low-temperature indirect heat), chicken breast, potatoes and other things I just threw into the pan out of excitement.

After two days, you could already see a significant difference in how the pan was darkening, getting closer to the black color of cast iron pans, and it was also time for the egg/omelet test.
As expected, the pan passed the test, and since then it has become the main pan for omelets at home.

One of the reasons I was too lazy to use the cast iron pan was the cleaning after use and the seasoning, mainly because the pan was heavy and hard to hold.
Although a carbon steel pan needs the same maintenance, the experience is completely different, mainly because the pan is lighter and very comfortable to hold and control.
In fact, the whole seasoning process became really simple and easy to do, and I almost never skip it.
The searing test after sous vide
After testing the pan long enough frying omelets, vegetables and meat, it was time to see how it performs at the highest heat and how good it is for a short, hard sear on meat after sous vide.
I heated the pan on the highest heat, dried the steak well and seared it for about 30 seconds per side.
The results were perfect every time. Just keep in mind that searing at such a high heat produces a crazy amount of smoke!

de Buyer Mineral B pros
The pan conducts heat more efficiently and faster than cast iron pans, which are also thicker. In addition, the pan stores and holds high heat (during the sear itself), which makes it the ideal pan for searing meat, especially after sous vide.
Weighs half as much (2.1 kg) as the cast iron pan.
A long handle that makes the pan easy to control and maintain.
A smooth finish that makes it easy and quick to build up a smooth non-stick layer.
Because of all these advantages, seasoning becomes much easier and quicker.

de Buyer Mineral B cons
The pan comes with a coated handle that's supposed to keep it from heating up, but because of this coating, the pan is limited to 10 minutes in the oven above 200°C (390°F). If you're used to putting your pan in the oven or a taboon, consider buying a different carbon steel pan, for example the Pro model or a pan by Matfer.
The amount of smoke when searing at high heat is simply out of control, and that's the downside of searing indoors in general.

Things to keep in mind about cast iron and carbon steel pans
This is exposed steel, meaning you need to keep it away from water and dry it quickly.
These pans need a maintenance process of seasoning (coating) to keep the non-stick layer and prevent rust.
Steel pans are sensitive to acidic foods (for example, tomato sauce), which can eat away at the coating, so it's important to keep searing/frying times with acidic ingredients short.
What's the difference between de Buyer's carbon steel lines?
Regular carbon steel line
A thin coated handle, limited to 10 minutes in the oven above 200°C.
Comes without beeswax.
Carbon Pro/Plus line (not Mineral B)
Stainless steel handle with no oven limit.
Comes without beeswax.
Carbon Mineral B
A thin coated handle, limited to 10 minutes in the oven above 200°C.
Comes with a beeswax coating.
Carbon Mineral B Pro
A hollow, designed stainless steel handle with no limit on oven use.
Comes with a beeswax coating.
One of the heaviest pans I've worked with. Heavier than the Mineral B.
If I remember correctly, regular/Plus carbon steel pans are slightly thinner than the Mineral B line.
Keep in mind that the pan's diameter includes the rim, and the flat cooking surface will be about 6 cm smaller.
What about stainless steel?
While this guide mainly describes my experience with a carbon steel pan and how to care for it and for cast iron pans, good stainless steel pans are also made for searing, oven roasting and even frying and deglazing (in my opinion, the most perfect pan for deglazing).
Their downside is the very high cost and the fact that they can't become non-stick.
Is a carbon steel pan worth it for sous vide?
After a month of using the pan, I must say it's a really fun pan to use:
The Maillard reaction (browning) is simply insane, so it's the ideal pan for a short, hard sear after sous vide.
The handle is very long and gives a good grip.
It's not as light as my stainless steel pan, but it's light enough to hold with one hand or to flip an omelet or vegetables
The non-stick layer is very effective, and making omelets with it is fun
Seasoning became a very simple and quick process because of the weight and the good grip
I have several excellent pans at home - a Lodge cast iron pan, an All-Clad stainless steel pan and now the de Buyer carbon steel pan, and each one has its own purpose.
I must say I was very surprised by the carbon steel pan, and since I bought it, I'm just looking for an excuse to use it every day. The seasoning process I was worried about, or more accurately too lazy to do, became part of the routine and takes just a few minutes, which makes this pan my favorite of them all.
P.S. - this isn't a blanket recommendation to go and buy only carbon steel.
If you don't have a good pan yet (or you're still using a grill pan... I don't blame you, but it's time to upgrade), or you're looking for a pan for searing after sous vide, any cast iron or carbon steel pan will upgrade your experience and the final result.

Using induction
I personally don't have an induction stove, but it was important for me to write about it, because it's a question that always comes up when buying a cast iron or carbon steel pan. According to comments online, seasoning can be slower (the heat concentrates in the center), so it's worth combining it with the oven.
What do I mean by the oven? After coating the pan with the layer of oil and wiping it off, put it upside down in the oven for an hour at 200°C (390°F).
Also, it's important not to turn the induction straight up to maximum, but to raise it gradually, and maybe not even all the way to maximum. A sudden change in heat can warp the steel (and cast iron pans can even shatter) and also make the pan "dance" on the stove.
I highly recommend checking the manufacturer's position on induction use before buying the pan.

* Seasoning according to the manufacturer: https://youtu.be/NHA4MSMKKoA
Recommended pans
de Buyer Mineral B pan, 28 cm
Amazon Germany (the cheapest when this guide was published) https://amzn.to/30NFkBF
Amazon US https://link.amazon/B04Q5Ng4a
Amazon UK https://amzn.to/3jNwr2q
de Buyer Mineral B Pro pan, 28 cm
de Buyer carbon steel pan, 26 cm
Lodge cast iron pan, 26 cm
Matfer pan, 28 cm
Accessories for cast iron and carbon steel pans
Polycarbonate pan scraper
Pan scrubbing pad
Seasoning wax
Frequently asked questions
Carbon steel or cast iron - which is better for searing after sous vide?
Both give great results. Carbon steel conducts heat faster, is lighter and is easier to make non-stick.
Can the de Buyer Mineral B go in the oven?
The regular Mineral B has a coated handle limited to 10 minutes above 200°C (390°F). The Mineral B Pro has a stainless steel handle with no oven limit.
Does a carbon steel pan become non-stick?
Yes. After a few days of searing and frying, mine passed the fried egg test.





Comments